Sunday, July 27, 2014

Module 8: Hold Fast

Module 8: Hold Fast by Blue Balliett


Book cover image: 




Book Summary:

Early Pearl and her family live in a small Chicago apartment, but are exceedingly happy together, reading extensively, reveling in the words of favorite family poet, Langston Hughes, saving and dreaming of a house of their own. However, soon there is a problem, Early’s father, Dash, has disappeared unexpectedly leaving an unsuspecting family caught in the middle of a mystery. After a violent break in that may or may not be related, the dwindling family finds themselves entwined in the city social services system and Early begins to use the lingering clues from her dad’s job in the public library and the book he left behind to try and discover what has happened to Dash and hopefully move them from the shelter back to the life they left behind.



APA Reference of Book:

Balliett, B. (2013). Hold fast. New York, NY: Scholastic Press.

Impressions:

I enjoyed this book as much as I once enjoyed sharing Balliett’s Chasing Vermeer with a classroom of students. The literary aspect of the family’s love of literature and Langston Hughes, the mystery of the disappearance of Dash and later the Antwerp diamond heist, and the realistic portrayal of life in the not often explored world of homelessness in an inner city combine to make a fantastic read.

Professional Review:

Gr 6-9--The four Pearls live in a one-room apartment in South Side Chicago, rejoicing in their love for reading and celebrating words and poetic rhythms while keeping their eye on the dream of a house of their own. Dash, the father, works at the library, quotes Langston Hughes, and takes on some extra work for a dealer of old books, hoping to build up the family nest egg. When he disappears, and a violent break-in forces Early; her mother, Sum; and her younger brother, Jubilation, to escape to a homeless shelter, they are sure that their father will show up soon and they will be together again. But Dash's strange disappearance and the police's refusal to believe that there is more to the story cause Early to summon her strength and follow the clues herself. Balliett paints a vivid picture, a literary composition reminiscent of an Impressionist painting, and the landscape of life as a child within the social-services system comes into focus through the eyes of an 11-year-old. Early's interactions with the other kids at the shelter and at school help her devise a letter-writing campaign about housing for the homeless that one hopes might gain a foothold in the real world. This is an engaging mystery in which books are both the problem and the solution, and the author shows that the fight to hold fast to your dreams rewards those who persevere. Excellent.
~~~~~~~~
By Cheryl Ashton, Amherst Public Library, OH

Ashton, C. (2013). [Review of Hold Fast by B. Balliett]. School Library Journal, 59(4), 156. Retrieved from

Library Uses:

For fans of the realistic fiction/historical fiction/mystery combo, Hold Fast is a great recommendation. Similar to Blue Balliett’s other mystery success, Chasing Vermeer, the puzzling nature the numbers in her dad’s book, the mystery of the diamond heist and the realistic look at homelessness in America, this is overall a great mystery to suggest to fans of the genre.

This would also make a good class read aloud - I know, not perfect for library use, but still a great use of this intriguing mystery.

Module 8: Eve

Module 8: Eve by Anna Carey


Book cover image:  

(http://theprettybooks.files.wordpress.com/2011/11/eve.png?w=676)


Book Summary:

Eve grows up as an orphan in a world devastated by a horrible disease as the King seeks to rebuild the”New America”. She excels at school, where they teach classical literature and teach the girls to fear boys and men, telling them they will soon go on to amazing careers in the City of Sand. Instead, Eve discovers they are actually being locked away to serve as glorified incubators for raising the children needed to repopulate New America. Eve escapes from the School and learns more about the outside world as she seeks Califia, a refuge from the King for girls like her. She and enemy turned friend Arden, come upon a group of boys on their own as well, where Eve meets Caleb. A romance begins and then the girls are betrayed and handed over to a bounty hunter. Eventually, they escape and Eve unknowingly uses a previously deciphered code to reach out to Caleb but it also sends the King’s soldiers after her as well. Together she and Caleb escape to Califia by killing several soldiers, however, Caleb is injured and turned away from Califia because it is a women’s only refuge. Eve is safe, but at a terrible price.


APA Reference of Book:

Carey, A. (2011). Eve. New York, NY: Harper.

Impressions:

Eve is an interesting post apocalyptic read. I found myself wondering about a bit of the background information the author left out, details about the disease and how the vaccines led to death and other such holes that might have been filled. I also wondered more about how the world had been brought back from the brink (This is addressed a little more in the second book, but still not to my satisfaction.) I liked Arden as a character and look forward to seeing more from her in later books. However, I felt there was more development needed in other outside characters such as Leif, who gave up the girls to the bounty hunter. I liked the codes and the fact that the bad guys had deciphered them made sense, but still came as a shock. I was only slightly surprised that Caleb was unable to stay in the women’s only camp, but look forward to further development from both characters. I do hope Eve remains a strong character and does not turn into a mopey, sappy, sad girl like Bella from Twilight.

Professional Review:

Gr 9 Up--Eve is orphaned by a devastating plague that killed 98 percent of the population. Twelve years later she is set to graduate from an all-girls orphanage, where the students have been promised bright futures in the careers of their choice. However, the day before graduation Eve discovers that they are actually going to be bound to beds, impregnated against their will, and forced endlessly to bear children in order to repopulate the country. This discovery is horrific indeed, or at least it would be if it made any sense. The plot and characters are undermined by huge logical holes in the dystopian world-building. The girls are taught to hate men through reinterpretations of classic literature, but why bother educating them at all when they are going to spend their lives as prisoners? When Eve (unsurprisingly) escapes, more discrepancies emerge. "The New America" is now ruled by a king who has a large army and runs the schools for orphan girls as well as work camps for orphan boys. But if depleted population is the problem, why are the orphan boys being mistreated and killed? Why separate the genders at all? When Eve and her former frenemy from the orphanage end up in a camp of feral boys and meet the muscular yet gentle Caleb, a predictable romance ensues. Carey's clever writing and imaginative storytelling have potential but ultimately cannot save this flawed novel.
~~~~~~~~
By Eliza Langhans, Hatfield Public Library, MA

Langhans, E. (2012). [Review of Eve by A. Carey]. School Library Journal, 58(1), 108. Retrieved from

Library Uses:

This book has the potential to be a popular series similar to Divergent and Twilight. The characters are not as fully developed, however the idea makes it a good read alike book choice for apocalyptic YA literature.

Friday, July 18, 2014

Module 7: The Wall

Module 7: The Wall by Peter Sis



Book cover image:  

(http://jacketupload.macmillanusa.com/jackets/high_res/jpgs/9780374347017.jpg)

Book Summary:

In a graphical memoir, Peter Sis tells a story in pictures, art, and journal entries. As a boy who loved music and drawing, life behind the Iron Curtain was restrictive, but it wasn’t until young adulthood that he began to realize just how much he disliked life under Soviet totalitarian reign.  Told at first  through mostly black and white lined drawings with splashes of color representing his creative nature and splashes of Communist red, the story is interspersed with snippets from his actual journals as well as pictures he drew as a child and photographs from his early years. He explores from his early days with the Young Pioneers to his teenage years wishing for jeans and playing rock and roll music.


APA Reference of Book:

Sís, P. (2007). The wall: growing up behind the Iron Curtain. New York, NY: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.

Impressions:

Remarkable use of multiple genres including biography, picture book, and memoir, Peter Sis’ book The Wall gives readers a glimpse of life behind the Iron Curtain during the Cold War. Since one of my historical fiction books, Countdown, dealt with the Cold War in the US, it was interesting to humbling to see the fear that went on in Czechoslovakia during the same time frame.
I had never really been exposed to much of that more recent history (we always ran out time in the school year for US history, so we never got much past the end of WWII.) It was very eye-opening and an interesting read.

Professional Review:

Gr 4 Up --Personal, political, passionate-these are among the qualities that readers have come to appreciate about Sís's autobiographical books such as The Three Golden Keys (Doubleday, 1994) and Tibet through the Red Box (Farrar, 1998). This layered foray into family and Czech history begins with succinct sentences at the bottom of each page. Captions accompanying the art-arranged in panels of varying size-fill in more details. The pacing and design of the compositions create their own rhythm, contributing much to the resulting polyphony. Sís immediately engages even his youngest audience with a naked, cherubic self-portrait, colored pencil in hand. The ensuing scenes of home and community life in Prague, rendered predominantly in black and white, are punctuated with Communist red and tiny fragments of color as the young artist experiments in the face of rigid conformity. The third-person narration achieves an understatement that helps to mitigate the more disturbing descriptions found in his double-spread journal entries. Bordered by Sís's youthful art, photographs, and propaganda posters, these selections depict his reality behind the Iron Curtain from 1954 to 1977. The recurring themes of music and art as important vehicles of self-expression, and the relationship between a government's inclination to embrace or suppress that creativity and the state's vitality, will resonate with teens. This celebration of the arts climaxes in a full-color spread à la Peter Max. Complex, multifaceted, rich in detail, this book shares the artist's specific heritage while connecting to universal longings. His concluding visions of freedom are both poignant and exhilarating.
~~~~~~~~
By Wendy Lukehart, Washington DC Public Library
Edited By Trevelyn E. Jones, Editor; Luann Toth, Managing Editor; Marlene Charnizon, Associate Editor; Daryl Grabarek, Contributing Editor; Henrietta Thornton-Verma, Contributing Editor and Dale Raben, Assistant Editor

Lukehart, W. (2007). [Review of The Wall: growing up behind the Iron Curtain by P. Sis]. School Library Journal, 53(8), 139-140. Retrieved fromhttp://libproxy.library.unt.edu:2069/login.aspx?direct=true&db=eue&AN=26218559&scope=site

Library Uses:
This is an engaging personal story of a famous children’s book artist, that I can see using to generate interest in biographies and memoirs.

Module 7: How They Croaked: The Awful Ends of the Awfully Famous

Module 7: How They croaked: The awful ends of the awfully famous by Georgia Bragg



Book cover image: (https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgBujc1dOvFbUd-2u9xTQCQFyam-bWNNga2wC1LqMN64Y3B8Vl20umOHdY4B1akeFnC-UIuRp6pgMnza6J_Sok-Lg8k69umwdGvgdl4itpb8LLYZ0ivIQBJzH65ExEPmyxfnwDuBzD9ijU/s1600/How+They+Croaked.jpg)

Book Summary:

Just as the title suggests, this book chronicles the lives and more interestingly the deaths of many historical figures. The nineteen individual biographies average about 8 pages each, including a main caricature illustration and relevant dates open each chapter, along with a snarky epithet. At the end of every biography, there is two pages of facts about the time period, how they died, and other interesting tidbits. Compiled mostly in chronological order, it is interesting to see the connections between the historical figures, which is summarized in a chart/web at the end.





APA Reference of Book:

Bragg, G., & O'Malley, K. (2011). How they croaked: the awful ends of the awfully famous. New York, NY: Walker & Company.

Impressions:

What I enjoyed most about this compilation is the tone of the writing - a tad sarcastic and stinging that appeals to me and young readers. I also enjoyed the fact that so many of the figures lives’ intertwined with one anothers. The connections web at the end  helped pull together all I caught while reading. With the catchy cover and title and the macabre content, I’m sure this book flies off the shelf all year long.

Professional Review:

Gr 5-9--King Tut died of malaria; Edgar Allan Poe is suspected to have had rabies. Beethoven and Galileo both met their ends due to lead poisoning. Fifteen other historical figures, including world leaders, writers, and scientists, were felled by things as mundane as pneumonia and as unpredictable as angry mobs. Each entry provides the circumstances of the person's death and gives context to those circumstances, from discussions of the political climate to medical practices of the time. Chapters are separated by a spread of brief facts related to the individual, the demise, or the era. Lively, full-page caricatures set in decorative frames appear throughout, along with spot illustrations. Back matter includes a lengthy list of sources. The sometimes-snarky writing gives the material a casual, conversational tone that will appeal to many readers. The title alone provides an easy booktalk; expect this one to be passed around and pored over.
~~~~~~~~
By Brandy Danner, Wilmington Memorial Library, MA

Danner, B. (2011). [Review of How they croaked: the awful ends of the awfully famous by G. Bragg]. School Library Journal, 57(4), 189-190. Retrieved from http://libproxy.library.unt.edu:2069/login.aspx?direct=true&db=eue&AN=59966764&scope=site

Library Uses:

With a good book talk maybe around October for Halloween themes or anytime for biographies, this book would fly off the shelves all year long. A perennial favorite, I doubt it would ever be shelved for long.  

Friday, July 11, 2014

Module 6: The Butterfly

Module 6: The Butterfly by Patricia Polacco

Book cover image:  
(http://www.the-best-childrens-books.org/image-files/polacco--butterfly.jpg)

Book Summary:

The Nazis have come to the small French village that Monique and her mom, Marcel, call home. Their tall, black boots and rough demeanor scare Monique, but she still feels safe at home. One night, late at night, she sees a “little white ghost” of a girl at the foot of her bed. It turns out to be a young Jewish girl, whose family Marcel is hiding as part of the underground resistance movement. One night a neighbor spots the two girls releasing a butterfly into the night, and they must tell Marcel about their clandestine meetings. They are not reprimanded, only now they must help the family run away in the night. They succeed only to get separated at the train station on the return trip. Monique sees many Jews being taken away by train and she hopes she has gotten on the correct train. She arrives home, exhausted and falls asleep on her bed, only to be awakened by a relieved Marcel at her safe return. Her new friend, Sevrine, successfully makes it out of France and sends a note with a picture of a butterfly to Monique announcing her safety.

APA Reference of Book:

Polacco, P. (2000). The butterfly. New York, NY: Philomel Books.

Impressions:

As always, I love Patricia Polacco’s touching, heartfelt stories. Knowing they are based on the real life experiences of her family, makes a bigger impact. The illustrations are warm and beautiful. I read this book aloud to my mother on a road trip, and even though she took French in high school, we both stumbled over some of the pronunciations. I will have to research the correct pronunciations if I intend to read this book aloud. As a huge fan of her books, Pink and Say, Thank You, Mr. Falker, Mr. Lincoln’s Way, and the Tapestry, The Butterfly did not disappoint.

Professional Review:

Gr 1-5 --Polacco relates the tale of her Aunt Monique to show, in picture-book terms, the suffering of the Jews during Nazi occupation and the courage of those who took part in the French Resistance. The setting is a small village; unbeknownst to the child, Monique's mother is hiding Jews in their basement. It is at night, when Sevrine emerges from the depths to peer out the window, that Monique awakens and the secret friendship begins. Polacco's use of color has never been more effective. The blackness, which starts on the endpapers, surrounds the girls' conversations, Sevrine's basement existence, the ditch hiding the two families as they flee to the next refuge, and the train car on Monique's return trip (she has become separated from her mother). In contrast are the light-filled scenes of Monique and her mother at breakfast, their sweet reunion at home, and, on the last page, mother and child surrounded by butterflies. Earlier, Monique had watched a soldier crush a papillon; later, she had taken a fluttering "kiss of an angel" inside for her friend. The bold pattern and heightened color of the insect provides a counterpoint to the equally dynamic black-on-red swastikas. Convincing in its portrayal of both the disturbing and humanitarian forces of the time, the title is not as dark or graphic as Robert Innocenti's Rose Blanche (Harcourt, 1996). An author's note relates the rest of the story: Sevrine survived and the friendship still flourishes. A perfect blend of art and story.
~~~~~~~~
By Wendy Lukehart, Dauphin County Library, Harrisburg, PA

Lukehart, W. (2000). [Review of The Butterfly by P. Polacco]. School Library Journal, 46(5), 151. Retrieved from http://libproxy.library.unt.edu:2069/login.aspx?direct=true&db=eue&AN=3074674&scope=site

Library Uses:

I will suggest this book as a companion to the Diary of Anne Frank as it is also a story of the Resistance fighters during WWII. I would pair it with a story of French Jews escaping if I found a book that fit more appropriately.

Module 6: Day of Tears

Module 5: Day of Tears by Julius Lester



Book cover image:  


(http://www.plymouth.lib.in.us/images/giovanni_lester.jpg)


Book Summary:

Day of Tears chronicles the largest auction of slaves in American History. It took place in Savannah, Georgia in early March 1859.  Hundreds of slaves and families were torn apart when Pierce Butler had to repay huge gambling debts. The story is told in dialogues and monologues from various characters’ perspectives. In between stories before, during, and after the auction takes place are interludes in which the reader gets a glimpse into the past and  future as the characters reminisce about the day’s events years after the fact. Generally, the story follows the Butler family, including a young slave girl, 12 year old Emma, whose father, Will, grew up with Pierce, even saving his life once. Pierce takes his daughters, Sarah and Frances, to the auction and at the last minute decides to take Emma to take care of Sarah, whom Emma coddles after her momma divorced Pierce because he owned slaves. Once at the auction, Butler is persuaded by the slave-seller and the buyer, the widowed Mistress Henfield of Kentucky, to sell Emma.  Emma is taken away and never sees her family or her beloved Sarah again. She does, however, make it to Kentucky, gets married, and eventually escapes to Canada via the Underground Railroad. The impact of the Day of Tears follows all the characters.


APA Reference of Book:


Lester, J. (2005). Day of tears: A novel in dialogue. New York, NY: Hyperion Books for Children.


Impressions:


It is a very emotionally told story. I was really impressed with the symbol of the rain and how often and well it was compared to the sadness of the slave auction. Descriptions such as God’s tears and fiery sorrow are just the beginning of the many comparisons of the rain and the auction. The flashbacks and flashforwards serve a dual purpose of giving the reader context as to what happens in the past and future as well as broadening the characterization and changes in the characters as time passes. The difference viewpoints of Sarah and her mother on the immorality of slavery versus Pierce Butler and Frances’ belief in the Southern way of life serves as great conflict throughout the short novel.


Professional Review:


Gr 6-9-- This powerful and engaging historical novel is told in dialogue and through monologues. It also moves around in time, from the period when the story takes place to "interludes," in which the various characters look back on these events years later. It begins with a factual event-the largest slave auction in United States history that took place in 1859 on Pierce Butler's plantation in Georgia. The book introduces Butler, his abolitionist ex-wife Fanny Kemble, their two daughters, the auctioneer, and a number of slaves sold to pay off Butler's gambling debts. Emma, a fictional house slave, is the centerpiece of the novel. She cares for the master's daughters and has been promised that she will never be sold. On the last day of the auction, Butler impulsively sells her to a woman from Kentucky. There she marries, runs away, and eventually gains her freedom in Canada. Lester has done an admirable job of portraying the simmering anger and aching sadness that the slaves must have felt. Each character is well drawn and believable. Both blacks and whites liberally use the word "nigger," which will be jarring to modern-day students. The text itself is easy to read and flows nicely. Different typefaces distinguish the characters' monologues, their dialogues with one another, and their memories. Still, middle school readers may have some difficulty following the plot until they get used to the unusual format. Altogether this novel does a superb job of showing the inhumanity of slavery. It begs to be read aloud, and it could be used in sections to produce some stunning reader's theatre.
~~~~~~~~
By Bruce Anne Shook, Mendenhall Middle School, Greensboro, NC; Trevelyn E. Jones, Editor; Luann Toth, Managing Editor; Marlene Charnizon, Associate Editor; Daryl Grabarek, Contributing Editor and Dale Raben, Assistant Editor


Shook, B., Jones, T. E., Toth, L., Charnizon, M., Grabarek, D., & Raben, D. (2005). [Review of Day of Tears: A Novel in Dialogue by J. Lester]. School Library Journal, 51(3), 214. Retrieved from http://libproxy.library.unt.edu:2069/login.aspx?direct=true&db=eue&AN=16409283&scope=site


Library Uses:

I will use this book not only as a great example of historical fiction, but mostly as an introduction to the dialogue style of writing. Young elementary and middle school students sometimes find dialogues hard to read, yet I think Day of Tears is a good example of this format. Plays are meant to be read aloud and while this one could be read aloud, I think its strength lies more in the ease by which readers can read this book alone. Getting to know the dialogue/monologue  format and garnering information from the stage directions is assisted by the many flashbacks and flashforwards providing background information.

Saturday, July 5, 2014

Module 5: Num8ers

Module 5: Num8ers by Rachel Ward

Book cover image:  

(http://marymo.net/mm_blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/02/num8ers.JPG)

Book Summary:

Quiet, loner protagonist Jem sees numbers when she makes eye contact with others. And those numbers, she learns, represent the date that the person will die. As such, she finds it hard to connect to those around her, but a classmate, Spider, is persistent and they become reluctant friends. When she finds herself in a line for the London Eye when a lot of people show the same death date (today’s), she panics and runs off. Tracked by officials believing them to be terrorists (or wanting to talk to them as witnesses), Jem and Spider find themselves on the run with only a few days until Spider’s time runs out. As their budding relationship grows, Jem slowly lets go of her feelings of isolation and begins to think that maybe her life does not need to be marked with such self-inflicted pain and isolation. When Spider is captured, Jem makes some friends that help her. She seeks sanctuary in a church and soon has bargained for Spider’s release. He arrives on his supposed last day yet Jem comes to the conclusion that it is her, not Spider who must die in order to stop the dates. However, her mind is changed in the discussion on the roof that follows and she gets down, but Spider is goofing around and falls from the roof to his death. Num8ers ends with Jem losing her “gift” while pregnant with Spider’s child, only to discover her son, Adam, has inherited it.

APA Reference of Book:

Ward, Rachel. Num8ers. New York, NY: Chicken House/Scholastic, 2010. Print.

Impressions:

Though this book took a little bit to get into because of the dialect used (English slang and language), the concept is one that intrigued me from the very beginning. I enjoyed following Jem’s development and changes throughout the novel. I think Spider is the more static character that helps Jem grow and improve over time. Num8ers is a stark, yet intelligent look at a science fiction possibility. I think not only will adolescents be drawn to this book, but adult readers will as well (as I know I was).

Professional Review:

Gr 8-10--10102001. That's Jem's mother's number. Jem saw it whenever she looked into her mother's eyes, but it wasn't until four years after the woman's fatal heroin overdose when Jem was 11 that she realized that the number was the date her mother would die. And it's not just that number that the teen sees--she knows when everyone will die by looking into their eyes. Isolating herself from the rest of humanity seems to be the only solution until Spider, a freakishly tall, twitchy mess of a boy, refuses to leave her alone. In spite of the fact that she knows his death date is only months away, she can't resist his overtures of friendship. One afternoon, while ditching school, they head for the London Eye tourist attraction. When Jem realizes that several people standing in line are fated to die that very day, she panics and takes off. Newspapers and television pick up the story, and Jem and Spider, targeted as the terrorists responsible for destroying the Eye, or at least witnesses, are on the run in a stolen car. Ward's debut novel is gritty, bold, and utterly unique. Jem's isolation and pain, hidden beneath a veneer of toughness, are palpable, and the ending is a real shocker. Teens who read Charles De Lint, Holly Black, and Melvin Burgess will take to this riveting book and eagerly await the upcoming sequel.
~~~~~~~~
By Jane Henriksen Baird, Anchorage Public Library, AK

Baird, J. (2010). [Review of the book Numbers by R. Ward]. School Library Journal, 56(1), 115-116. Retrieved from http://libproxy.library.unt.edu:2069/login.aspx?direct=true&db=eue&AN=47392479&scope=site

Library Uses:

With the flashy cover and title that has a number in it, I think this book makes an excellent one to use in a book display featuring Sci-Fi books. It is also a different and engaging book in that the setting is London and often such a difference encourages students to give it a try.

Thursday, July 3, 2014

Module 5: The Miraculous Journey of Edward Tulane

Module 5: The Miraculous Journey of Edward Tulane by Kate DiCamillo


Book cover image:  












(http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-DSfy50Ydy7k/ULoWrvBDEgI/AAAAAAAACZE/fU4qlWtg7xw/s1600/Edward+Tulane.jpg)


Book Summary:


Kate DiCamillo’s story of a china toy rabbit touches on themes of loss, friendship, and love. When we are first introduced to Edward, he is selfish, not sharing the deep devotion his owner, Abilene, shows him. One night, her grandmother tells a story to the two of them about a princess who never reciprocated the love others showed her. Edward does not get the point of the story.  Soon they are on an ocean trip and Edward mistakenly goes overboard, beginning his many travels. Under the deep sea, Edward first feels fear and we begin to see the changes he is undergoing. Through the next few owners, Edward begins to feel love for his humans, caring more and more until, after watching his young Sarah Ruth die, and getting his head smashed by her father, Edward finally decides that love is too painful to go on. However, he is soon repaired and an old toy gives him the wise advice that he must open his heart for someone to love him. It is then that his beloved Abilene (all grown up now) comes in with her daughter and Edward feels complete. The lesson he learns of humility and love is one that many can benefit from.


APA Reference of Book:


DiCamillo, K., and Bagram, I. (2006). The Miraculous Journey of Edward Tulane. Cambridge, MA: Candlewick.


Impressions:


I was quite impressed by this short story full of lessons for young and old. It was an endearing story, but it was different from DiCamillo’s other stories. The cover and illustrations make it seem as if it is more like Because of Winn Dixie, but with the dark themes and more advanced vocabulary make this book one that is probably more suited for middle school or even adult learners. Young children expecting a fun story similar to Corduroy by Don Freeman, will find a story that may not interest them. The message of grandmother’s story is vague and might take a little bit to sink in for younger readers.It does have some great themes and I think even the youngest of readers would benefit from reading this with an adult or older sibling to discuss it with.


Professional Review:


Gr 3-6-- This achingly beautiful story shows a true master of writing at her very best. Edward Tulane is an exceedingly vain, cold-hearted china rabbit owned by 10-year-old Abilene Tulane, who dearly loves him. Her grandmother relates a fairy tale about a princess who never felt love; she then whispers to Edward that he disappoints her. His path to redemption begins when he falls overboard during the family's ocean journey. Sinking to the bottom of the sea where he will spend 297 days,Edward feels his first emotion-fear. Caught in a fisherman's net, he lives with the old man and his wife and begins to care about his humans. Then their adult daughter takes him to the dump, where a dog and a hobo find him. They ride the rails together until Edward is cruelly separated from them. His heart is truly broken when next owner, four-year-old Sarah Ruth, dies. He recalls Abilene's grandmother with a new sense of humility, wishing she knew that he has learned to love. When his head is shattered by an angry man, Edward wants to join Sarah Ruth but those he has loved convince him to live. Repaired by a doll store owner, he closes his heart to love, as it is too painful, until a wise doll tells him that he that he must open his heart for someone to love him. This superb book is beautifully written in spare yet stirring language. The tender look at the changes from arrogance to grateful loving is perfectly delineated. Ibatoulline's lovely sepia-toned gouache illustrations and beautifully rendered color plates are exquisite. An ever-so-marvelous tale.
~~~~~~~~
By B. Allison Gray, John Jermain Library, Sag Harbor, NY


Gray, B. (2006). [Review of The Miraculous Journey of Edward Tulane by K. DiCamillo]. School Library Journal, 52(2), 95. Retrieved from
 http://libproxy.library.unt.edu:2069/login.aspx?direct=true&db=eue&AN=19583094&scope=site

Library Uses:

I think this would make a great read aloud. The intense topics and lessons learned by Edward allow for deep discussion and the many changes Edward goes through show great character development over time.