Module 8: Eve by Anna Carey
(http://theprettybooks.files.wordpress.com/2011/11/eve.png?w=676)
Book Summary:
Eve grows up as an orphan in a world devastated by a horrible disease as the King seeks to rebuild the”New America”. She excels at school, where they teach classical literature and teach the girls to fear boys and men, telling them they will soon go on to amazing careers in the City of Sand. Instead, Eve discovers they are actually being locked away to serve as glorified incubators for raising the children needed to repopulate New America. Eve escapes from the School and learns more about the outside world as she seeks Califia, a refuge from the King for girls like her. She and enemy turned friend Arden, come upon a group of boys on their own as well, where Eve meets Caleb. A romance begins and then the girls are betrayed and handed over to a bounty hunter. Eventually, they escape and Eve unknowingly uses a previously deciphered code to reach out to Caleb but it also sends the King’s soldiers after her as well. Together she and Caleb escape to Califia by killing several soldiers, however, Caleb is injured and turned away from Califia because it is a women’s only refuge. Eve is safe, but at a terrible price.
APA Reference of Book:
Carey, A. (2011). Eve. New York, NY: Harper.
Impressions:
Eve is an interesting post apocalyptic read. I found myself wondering about a bit of the background information the author left out, details about the disease and how the vaccines led to death and other such holes that might have been filled. I also wondered more about how the world had been brought back from the brink (This is addressed a little more in the second book, but still not to my satisfaction.) I liked Arden as a character and look forward to seeing more from her in later books. However, I felt there was more development needed in other outside characters such as Leif, who gave up the girls to the bounty hunter. I liked the codes and the fact that the bad guys had deciphered them made sense, but still came as a shock. I was only slightly surprised that Caleb was unable to stay in the women’s only camp, but look forward to further development from both characters. I do hope Eve remains a strong character and does not turn into a mopey, sappy, sad girl like Bella from Twilight.
Professional Review:
Gr 9 Up--Eve is orphaned by a devastating plague that killed 98 percent of the population. Twelve years later she is set to graduate from an all-girls orphanage, where the students have been promised bright futures in the careers of their choice. However, the day before graduation Eve discovers that they are actually going to be bound to beds, impregnated against their will, and forced endlessly to bear children in order to repopulate the country. This discovery is horrific indeed, or at least it would be if it made any sense. The plot and characters are undermined by huge logical holes in the dystopian world-building. The girls are taught to hate men through reinterpretations of classic literature, but why bother educating them at all when they are going to spend their lives as prisoners? When Eve (unsurprisingly) escapes, more discrepancies emerge. "The New America" is now ruled by a king who has a large army and runs the schools for orphan girls as well as work camps for orphan boys. But if depleted population is the problem, why are the orphan boys being mistreated and killed? Why separate the genders at all? When Eve and her former frenemy from the orphanage end up in a camp of feral boys and meet the muscular yet gentle Caleb, a predictable romance ensues. Carey's clever writing and imaginative storytelling have potential but ultimately cannot save this flawed novel.
~~~~~~~~
By Eliza Langhans, Hatfield Public Library, MA
Langhans, E. (2012). [Review of Eve by A. Carey]. School Library Journal, 58(1), 108. Retrieved from
Library Uses:
This book has the potential to be a popular series similar to Divergent and Twilight. The characters are not as fully developed, however the idea makes it a good read alike book choice for apocalyptic YA literature.
No comments:
Post a Comment