Module 5: Day of Tears by Julius Lester
Book cover image:
(http://www.plymouth.lib.in.us/images/giovanni_lester.jpg)
Book Summary:
Day of Tears chronicles the largest auction of slaves in American History. It took place in Savannah, Georgia in early March 1859. Hundreds of slaves and families were torn apart when Pierce Butler had to repay huge gambling debts. The story is told in dialogues and monologues from various characters’ perspectives. In between stories before, during, and after the auction takes place are interludes in which the reader gets a glimpse into the past and future as the characters reminisce about the day’s events years after the fact. Generally, the story follows the Butler family, including a young slave girl, 12 year old Emma, whose father, Will, grew up with Pierce, even saving his life once. Pierce takes his daughters, Sarah and Frances, to the auction and at the last minute decides to take Emma to take care of Sarah, whom Emma coddles after her momma divorced Pierce because he owned slaves. Once at the auction, Butler is persuaded by the slave-seller and the buyer, the widowed Mistress Henfield of Kentucky, to sell Emma. Emma is taken away and never sees her family or her beloved Sarah again. She does, however, make it to Kentucky, gets married, and eventually escapes to Canada via the Underground Railroad. The impact of the Day of Tears follows all the characters.
APA Reference of Book:
Lester, J. (2005). Day of tears: A novel in dialogue. New York, NY: Hyperion Books for Children.
Impressions:
It is a very emotionally told story. I was really impressed with the symbol of the rain and how often and well it was compared to the sadness of the slave auction. Descriptions such as God’s tears and fiery sorrow are just the beginning of the many comparisons of the rain and the auction. The flashbacks and flashforwards serve a dual purpose of giving the reader context as to what happens in the past and future as well as broadening the characterization and changes in the characters as time passes. The difference viewpoints of Sarah and her mother on the immorality of slavery versus Pierce Butler and Frances’ belief in the Southern way of life serves as great conflict throughout the short novel.
Professional Review:
Gr 6-9-- This powerful and engaging historical novel is told in dialogue and through monologues. It also moves around in time, from the period when the story takes place to "interludes," in which the various characters look back on these events years later. It begins with a factual event-the largest slave auction in United States history that took place in 1859 on Pierce Butler's plantation in Georgia. The book introduces Butler, his abolitionist ex-wife Fanny Kemble, their two daughters, the auctioneer, and a number of slaves sold to pay off Butler's gambling debts. Emma, a fictional house slave, is the centerpiece of the novel. She cares for the master's daughters and has been promised that she will never be sold. On the last day of the auction, Butler impulsively sells her to a woman from Kentucky. There she marries, runs away, and eventually gains her freedom in Canada. Lester has done an admirable job of portraying the simmering anger and aching sadness that the slaves must have felt. Each character is well drawn and believable. Both blacks and whites liberally use the word "nigger," which will be jarring to modern-day students. The text itself is easy to read and flows nicely. Different typefaces distinguish the characters' monologues, their dialogues with one another, and their memories. Still, middle school readers may have some difficulty following the plot until they get used to the unusual format. Altogether this novel does a superb job of showing the inhumanity of slavery. It begs to be read aloud, and it could be used in sections to produce some stunning reader's theatre.
~~~~~~~~
By Bruce Anne Shook, Mendenhall Middle School, Greensboro, NC; Trevelyn E. Jones, Editor; Luann Toth, Managing Editor; Marlene Charnizon, Associate Editor; Daryl Grabarek, Contributing Editor and Dale Raben, Assistant Editor
Shook, B., Jones, T. E., Toth, L., Charnizon, M., Grabarek, D., & Raben, D. (2005). [Review of Day of Tears: A Novel in Dialogue by J. Lester]. School Library Journal, 51(3), 214. Retrieved from http://libproxy.library.unt.edu:2069/login.aspx?direct=true&db=eue&AN=16409283&scope=site
Library Uses:
I will use this book not only as a great example of historical fiction, but mostly as an introduction to the dialogue style of writing. Young elementary and middle school students sometimes find dialogues hard to read, yet I think Day of Tears is a good example of this format. Plays are meant to be read aloud and while this one could be read aloud, I think its strength lies more in the ease by which readers can read this book alone. Getting to know the dialogue/monologue format and garnering information from the stage directions is assisted by the many flashbacks and flashforwards providing background information.
No comments:
Post a Comment