Friday, July 11, 2014

Module 6: The Butterfly

Module 6: The Butterfly by Patricia Polacco

Book cover image:  
(http://www.the-best-childrens-books.org/image-files/polacco--butterfly.jpg)

Book Summary:

The Nazis have come to the small French village that Monique and her mom, Marcel, call home. Their tall, black boots and rough demeanor scare Monique, but she still feels safe at home. One night, late at night, she sees a “little white ghost” of a girl at the foot of her bed. It turns out to be a young Jewish girl, whose family Marcel is hiding as part of the underground resistance movement. One night a neighbor spots the two girls releasing a butterfly into the night, and they must tell Marcel about their clandestine meetings. They are not reprimanded, only now they must help the family run away in the night. They succeed only to get separated at the train station on the return trip. Monique sees many Jews being taken away by train and she hopes she has gotten on the correct train. She arrives home, exhausted and falls asleep on her bed, only to be awakened by a relieved Marcel at her safe return. Her new friend, Sevrine, successfully makes it out of France and sends a note with a picture of a butterfly to Monique announcing her safety.

APA Reference of Book:

Polacco, P. (2000). The butterfly. New York, NY: Philomel Books.

Impressions:

As always, I love Patricia Polacco’s touching, heartfelt stories. Knowing they are based on the real life experiences of her family, makes a bigger impact. The illustrations are warm and beautiful. I read this book aloud to my mother on a road trip, and even though she took French in high school, we both stumbled over some of the pronunciations. I will have to research the correct pronunciations if I intend to read this book aloud. As a huge fan of her books, Pink and Say, Thank You, Mr. Falker, Mr. Lincoln’s Way, and the Tapestry, The Butterfly did not disappoint.

Professional Review:

Gr 1-5 --Polacco relates the tale of her Aunt Monique to show, in picture-book terms, the suffering of the Jews during Nazi occupation and the courage of those who took part in the French Resistance. The setting is a small village; unbeknownst to the child, Monique's mother is hiding Jews in their basement. It is at night, when Sevrine emerges from the depths to peer out the window, that Monique awakens and the secret friendship begins. Polacco's use of color has never been more effective. The blackness, which starts on the endpapers, surrounds the girls' conversations, Sevrine's basement existence, the ditch hiding the two families as they flee to the next refuge, and the train car on Monique's return trip (she has become separated from her mother). In contrast are the light-filled scenes of Monique and her mother at breakfast, their sweet reunion at home, and, on the last page, mother and child surrounded by butterflies. Earlier, Monique had watched a soldier crush a papillon; later, she had taken a fluttering "kiss of an angel" inside for her friend. The bold pattern and heightened color of the insect provides a counterpoint to the equally dynamic black-on-red swastikas. Convincing in its portrayal of both the disturbing and humanitarian forces of the time, the title is not as dark or graphic as Robert Innocenti's Rose Blanche (Harcourt, 1996). An author's note relates the rest of the story: Sevrine survived and the friendship still flourishes. A perfect blend of art and story.
~~~~~~~~
By Wendy Lukehart, Dauphin County Library, Harrisburg, PA

Lukehart, W. (2000). [Review of The Butterfly by P. Polacco]. School Library Journal, 46(5), 151. Retrieved from http://libproxy.library.unt.edu:2069/login.aspx?direct=true&db=eue&AN=3074674&scope=site

Library Uses:

I will suggest this book as a companion to the Diary of Anne Frank as it is also a story of the Resistance fighters during WWII. I would pair it with a story of French Jews escaping if I found a book that fit more appropriately.

No comments:

Post a Comment